LMC vinyl headliner vs USA1 perforated vinyl headliner

[WranglerTJForum]

Is one of these brands superior to the other in regard to quality replacement headliners?

I'm looking at this one:

1973-76 Square Body Chevy & GMC Truck Perforated Vinyl Headliner, Original Colors

1973-76 Square Body Chevy & GMC Truck Perforated Vinyl Headliner, Original Colors

www.usa1industries.com

And this one:

https://www.lmctruck.com/interior/headliners/cc-1973-87-abs-plastic-headliners

Anyone got photos of any of these in their truck?

 

[Old Guy Bill]

I used the LMC unit. You'll need the trim pieces kit for it also.
It worked great for my old build.

 

[1STLS1]

USA1 stuff is usually high quality BUT, verify they have it in stock and a shipping date before giving them your card. They play a game with using your money while they wait for the product from another vendor which, during my several experiences with them, can go into months before it ships. Don't trust the website stating it's "in stock", call them and verify it.

 

[ali_c20]

I have the usa1 perforated vinyl headliner.
Not in the truck yet as projects times always explode on my projects
Can't say anything bout fitment but quality, look and feel is great.

 

[Bloodhound1981]

I have the LMC one with black perforated vinyl. I am very happy with it, looks great.

 

[75 short]

I used classic parts in my 75 perfect replacement very happy with them

 

[Finkaire]

Slam dunk for an upholstery guy, had my visors done at the same time