Electric vs mechanical fan

Disclaimer: Links on this page pointing to Amazon, eBay and other sites may include affiliate code. If you click them and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission.

86Peter454

Full Access Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2017
Posts
284
Reaction score
266
Location
Missouri
First Name
Matt
Truck Year
1986
Truck Model
C10 Scottsdale
Engine Size
454
any of you guys pay for motor trend on demand?

the Engine Masters guys tested some of this and if i recall correctly. if going mechanical fan your gonna want a clutched fan.

the advantage to electric is its not on all the time when it is on the draw from the alternator will likely kill more power than the mechanical fan. (again that is if i remember correctly)

like someone else said pay attention to amp draw the lower the better really.
 

shiftpro

Full Access Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2012
Posts
4,855
Reaction score
6,085
Location
BC Canada
First Name
shiftpro
Truck Year
73-87
Truck Model
1500, 2500, 3500
Engine Size
350, 383, 454, 496!
any of you guys pay for motor trend on demand?

the Engine Masters guys tested some of this and if i recall correctly. if going mechanical fan your gonna want a clutched fan.

the advantage to electric is its not on all the time when it is on the draw from the alternator will likely kill more power than the mechanical fan. (again that is if i remember correctly)

like someone else said pay attention to amp draw the lower the better really.

The Engine Master shows eventually all make it to youtube.
Yes I agree a mechanical fan is best it it has a clutch.
Most of the Engine Master's data I find only really applies to high rpm racing attitudes... not daily driver.
Like the one about 2.5" exhaust vs 3"... yes the 3" produced more power but not u til after 5000rpm.

The dented header show was pretty good and related to reality.

But your last remark about fans with low amp draw I can not agree with that. Low amp pull = low cfms...
High amperage alternators do use more power to spin, but I don't imagine it would offset a 20 lbs clutch and fan. Move up to
alternators with enough power to reliably weld and heck yeah you have to increase rpms under load!
 

4WDKC

Full Access Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2016
Posts
2,366
Reaction score
1,090
Location
Southern Florida
First Name
Kacy
Truck Year
1987
Truck Model
V10
Engine Size
350
if its working fine and your not searching for every last tenth at the track leave it. If its not working its a good time to switch but, you will need a fan with a shroud that covers 70% of the radiator. Fans without shrouds only work in situations where the radiator is bigger than needed resulting in only needing minor air flow to cool or low horsepower situations. My vette had LT1 fbody fans without the shroud and they couldnt cool it. I swapped to some Ford focus fans in their much smaller shroud cooled it fine.
 

Casey Little

Junior Member
Joined
May 10, 2019
Posts
8
Reaction score
0
Location
Pennsylvania
First Name
Casey
Truck Year
1983
Truck Model
C10
Engine Size
350
Thank you all for the input. I think I'm just going to leave it alone. I guess if it's not broke don't fix it. I'm also running my temp sensor in the water outlet right above the thermostat is that ok or should I be running it in the intake or the head?
 

shiftpro

Full Access Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2012
Posts
4,855
Reaction score
6,085
Location
BC Canada
First Name
shiftpro
Truck Year
73-87
Truck Model
1500, 2500, 3500
Engine Size
350, 383, 454, 496!
If you upgrade to a high compression big block then we can return to this conversation.
 

86Peter454

Full Access Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2017
Posts
284
Reaction score
266
Location
Missouri
First Name
Matt
Truck Year
1986
Truck Model
C10 Scottsdale
Engine Size
454
The Engine Master shows eventually all make it to youtube.
Yes I agree a mechanical fan is best it it has a clutch.
Most of the Engine Master's data I find only really applies to high rpm racing attitudes... not daily driver.
Like the one about 2.5" exhaust vs 3"... yes the 3" produced more power but not u til after 5000rpm.

The dented header show was pretty good and related to reality.

But your last remark about fans with low amp draw I can not agree with that. Low amp pull = low cfms...
High amperage alternators do use more power to spin, but I don't imagine it would offset a 20 lbs clutch and fan. Move up to
alternators with enough power to reliably weld and heck yeah you have to increase rpms under load!

i agree they often look at just wide open throttle situations.

but a lot of the info can still apply. when cruising down the road if your not spinning a fan off the crank then you have more power available if need be. usually your electric fans should not be on if you are going down the road. just when in traffic and drive threw line and such. this should net you better fuel economy (theoretically).

you are right the lower amps the lower the cfm the idea really would be to do you best to get the fan with the least amp draw that will still cool your motor. other option may be to run multiple fans but on separate switches. this would mean you could keep things cool with one fan but if things get really hot you just know you will sacrifice your power for keeping the engine cool.

i certainly dont think electric fans are a must have but i think they would be a decent upgrade if the price is right.
 

shiftpro

Full Access Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2012
Posts
4,855
Reaction score
6,085
Location
BC Canada
First Name
shiftpro
Truck Year
73-87
Truck Model
1500, 2500, 3500
Engine Size
350, 383, 454, 496!
i agree they often look at just wide open throttle situations.

but a lot of the info can still apply. when cruising down the road if your not spinning a fan off the crank then you have more power available if need be. usually your electric fans should not be on if you are going down the road. just when in traffic and drive threw line and such. this should net you better fuel economy (theoretically).

you are right the lower amps the lower the cfm the idea really would be to do you best to get the fan with the least amp draw that will still cool your motor. other option may be to run multiple fans but on separate switches. this would mean you could keep things cool with one fan but if things get really hot you just know you will sacrifice your power for keeping the engine cool.

i certainly dont think electric fans are a must have but i think they would be a decent upgrade if the price is right.

My setup will be for a high compression 496. The Dakota digital control I have in the link can be set to have only one fan run unless more cooling is needed. I'll route the wiring so I can easily switch plugs like maybe twice a year so the 'aux' fan gets some use time. Try to wear out both fans more or less the same.
 

4WDKC

Full Access Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2016
Posts
2,366
Reaction score
1,090
Location
Southern Florida
First Name
Kacy
Truck Year
1987
Truck Model
V10
Engine Size
350
Thank you all for the input. I think I'm just going to leave it alone. I guess if it's not broke don't fix it. I'm also running my temp sensor in the water outlet right above the thermostat is that ok or should I be running it in the intake or the head?

I prefer it in the head so I can see what the temps are doing.
 

Jrgunn5150

Questionable methods
Joined
Jan 11, 2016
Posts
2,739
Reaction score
1,412
Location
Ionia Mi
First Name
J.R.
Truck Year
1979
Truck Model
C10
Engine Size
6.slow
I prefer it in the head so I can see what the temps are doing.

Same, I want to know at all times, closer to the combustion chamber.
 

Arkansas_V8

Proud Redneck
Joined
Jul 1, 2019
Posts
3,022
Reaction score
3,961
Location
Springdale, Arkansas
First Name
Brent
Truck Year
88
Truck Model
V20 Suburban
Engine Size
5.7
any of you guys pay for motor trend on demand?

the Engine Masters guys tested some of this and if i recall correctly. if going mechanical fan your gonna want a clutched fan.

the advantage to electric is its not on all the time when it is on the draw from the alternator will likely kill more power than the mechanical fan. (again that is if i remember correctly)

like someone else said pay attention to amp draw the lower the better really.


I pay for MotorTrend, and I am so damn excited about Top Gear August 30th.
 

Arkansas_V8

Proud Redneck
Joined
Jul 1, 2019
Posts
3,022
Reaction score
3,961
Location
Springdale, Arkansas
First Name
Brent
Truck Year
88
Truck Model
V20 Suburban
Engine Size
5.7
yo me too!


I was pissed when it got pushed back from the 4th the first time.

Hoping they dont screw us again.


Like the new setup? I really like the new layout of the app.

I have been a member since Beta, it is way better now.
 

roundhouse

Full Access Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2014
Posts
669
Reaction score
527
Location
atlanta ga
First Name
justin
Truck Year
77,78,79,80 ?
Truck Model
K10
Engine Size
350
I pay for MotorTrend, and I am so damn excited about Top Gear August 30th.
I stopped watching it when Clarkson, May and the Hamster left
The replacement crew was not funny

But then their Grand Tour just wasn’t the same , it just wasn’t as funny as TG

Oh well nothing lasts forever

Mrs Roundhouse cares not a bit about cars but she loves watching top gear because it was so funny
 

Arkansas_V8

Proud Redneck
Joined
Jul 1, 2019
Posts
3,022
Reaction score
3,961
Location
Springdale, Arkansas
First Name
Brent
Truck Year
88
Truck Model
V20 Suburban
Engine Size
5.7
I stopped watching it when Clarkson, May and the Hamster left
The replacement crew was not funny

But then their Grand Tour just wasn’t the same , it just wasn’t as funny as TG

Oh well nothing lasts forever

Mrs Roundhouse cares not a bit about cars but she loves watching top gear because it was so funny

Seasons 2 to the end on the app, my wife is the same way.

She told me to tell you atleast they watch it with us. Lol
 

Matt69olds

Full Access Member
Joined
Jan 8, 2018
Posts
2,338
Reaction score
3,571
Location
Central Indiana
First Name
Matt
Truck Year
81
Truck Model
GMC 1/2 ton
Engine Size
455 Olds
Nothing beats a big engine driven fan. If electric fans were superior to engine driven fans my Cummins powered ram wouldn’t have a mechanical clutch.

The important part of this discussion is how the fan is controlled. My Cummins has a mechanical fan driven by the engine, but has a electric clutch controlling it. Until the engine is hot enough to need the fan, it doesn’t do much. Same thing with a thermal fan clutch, just isn’t as refined as the electric clutch. The fan basically free wheels until the engine is hot enough to engage the clutch.

As for mechanical fans robbing power, I have tried completely removing the fan and clutch from my 69 Olds at the track. There was ZERO difference in ET, or mph. This was on a Friday night test and tune, made a baseline pass, removed the fan, made a couple passes, and reinstalled the fan, also with no change. Thermal clutch fans just don’t take much power to drive them, until you need the added airflow.
 

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
41,859
Posts
903,668
Members
33,372
Latest member
83elcowes
Top